The chat seem pretty consistent that few if any want VR to put Server First in the game as it would promote a Rush to End Game where some players would miss out on content (personally I don't see that valid as a Dwarf will be missing out on Elf content, and a Elf will be missing out on Skar content already... but that's for debate in another thread)
SO, what about "Server Record" (until somebody comes up with a better name) instead of Server First.
"Server Record: Dwarror is the oldest living level 20 Dwarf Warrior with 10 days played as level 20!"
This would be a live moving goal, not a one time thing Somebody could always come along and "beat" it. It also would not promote a rush to end game. It could also be tied into Progeny for "Second Generation Server Records"